Preface to Thirukkural
Varahaneri Venkatesa Subramaniam
Aiyar, also known as V.V.S. Aiyar was an Indian Revolutionary from
Trichurapalli, Tamilnadu. He fought against British Colonial Rule in India. He
was also a Tamil writer and is considered as the father of modern Tamil short
story. He translated the Ramavatharam of
Kambar and Thirukkural in English.
V.V.S.Aiyar
translated the entire work of the Thirukkural text in English prose, which
became the first complete English translation by a native scholar. Aiyar’s work
is considered by various scholars as the most scholarly of all the English
translations made until then, including those by native English Scholars. Aiyar
translated the Thirukkural in 962.
The Need for his
Translation
V.V.S.Aiyar
starts his work with a preface, in which he gives the reason for his
translation of Thirukkural . Aiyar
felt bad that the book which is considered by the Tamil people as the Tamil Veda, the Universal Veda, the later
Veda, the Divine Book was confined to only the Hindustan people for a very
long time. The first translation of Thirukkural
by the Jesuit missionary Constantius Beschi into Latin was very valuable
though it was only in manuscript form. But still this translation has been a
guide for Dr. Graul for his German and Latin translation of Thirukkural. The translation done by M.
Ariel and M de Dumsat into French is
found in the library of Paris. F.W. Ellis, W.H.Drew, E. J.Robinson, J. Lazarus
and the late Rev. G. U. Pope are some of the English translators of the Thirukkural.
The
translation done by Drew and Ramanuja Kavirayar was the best translation of Thirukkural in English but only 63
chapters were translated and it was out of print too. Dr. G. U. Pope has added
valuable notes and has prepared a combined lexicon and concordance to his
translation of Thirukkural. Except
for the translations done by Robinson, Lazarus and Graul, Aiyar was not
satisfied with the other translations and hence he chose to translate Thirukkural on his own.
While
translating Thirukkural in English
the author felt that English version of the Bible will be of great help. The
proverbs, Wisdom of Solomon and the Sermons of Jesus mentioned in the Bible
will be of great help to retain the vigour of the Kural in English. So for Drew
and G. U. Pope it would have been easier to adopt the style of the Bible for
the translation of Thirukkural. But
still, Aiyar felt that Drew gave a feeble translation and Pope deformed the
grand thought by giving them unnatural expression. Even the translations of the
chapter headings by Pope are not up to the mark. Thus Aiyar felt that both Drew
and Pope lacked the force and vigour of the original.
About
Thiruvalluvar
Aiyar
tells that just like other great men of the past, very little is known about
the great saint Thiruvalluvar. The word Thiruvalluvar means “the devotee of the
Valluva caste”. The Valluvas used to
carry out the order of the king. According to traditions it is believed that he
was born in Madura to a Brahman father and a pariah mother and married a
Bhagavan. He had 6 siblings. He lived in Mylapore, Madras. He chose the
profession of weaving as he thought it was the most innocent of all the
professions.
Many
stories were available regarding his married life. Vasuki, the wife of
Thiruvalluvar became the image of ideal wife. Her artless simplicity and
unquestioning obedience was looked upon by everybody. When a Sage asked
Thiruvallur about marriage, thiruvallur asked the sage to stay with him and
find the answer on his own and the sage confirmed that if one gets a wife like
Vasuki one can get married otherwise its best to remain single all their life.
Life of
Thiruvallur has changed a lot after the death of his wife. Once his wife deid
he denounced all the worldly pleasures and chose the ascetic life.
Thirukkural
Thirukkural
is divided into 3 parts, the first one talks of Righteousness and second one
talks about the Politics and the third one is regarding the Love. According to the
Hindus these 3 virtues along with Heavenly Bliss are the four main objectives
of lifeiruvallu. Though Thiruvalluvar has not spoken about heavenly bliss , the
first part of the Kural explains the way of self-realization, which is the
highest happiness a man can attain.
Part I –
Righteousness
The
author speaks about the life of the householder and the life of the ascetic in
this part. In the first -9 chapters the author points out the virtues needed
for a good husband, good father, good neighbour and a good man and the next -3
chapters of the Ist part focused on the ascetic life. the first section of Part
I, end with the chapter titled Fame and the 2nd part ends with
Destiny, which is the resultant of all his thoughts and actions in previous
births.
Aiyar
makes a special mention of verse 76, 207, 247, 363, which are the best. The chiefest
blessing according to the great sage are an honourable home and worthy off
spring. The sages love for children is noteworthy. He says that the touch of
children is the delight of the body and he also adds up that those who have not
heard to the prattle of their kids alone will be attracted by guitar and the
flute. Next he tells about the chief virtues of man. Love of mankind and the
honouring of the guest are the chief virtues of man.
One who
is devoid of love is like a dry tree in wilderness. He speaks of the virtues
that has to be followed and one has to avoid in life. uprightness, forgiveness,
obligation, good will, charity are the virtues and fornication, envy, coveting,
slander, vain speaking, injuring the neighbour are the vices that one has to
avoid in life.
Once he
fulfills his duty towards the society, he needs to focus on the life that is
beyond the death. For this he has to follow a stricter discipline than before. He
has to follow mercy, avoid flesh meat, mortify his body, concentrate his
thoughts and aim to attain spiritual power and vision. He should strictly
adhere to the truth, conquer his anger and temptation. He has to realize that
the phenomenal life is no better that a dream and a shadow. Once he attain the
ascetic, he realizes that Heaven is near to him than the Earth. Killing of the
Desire is the last chapter of the Life of Ascetic.
The chapter
on destiny explains about “ul”. It tells
how all the unspent force of a man’s action have an effect on him. According to
the Hindu belief both the good and bad action have an unseen effect in all his
actions. To explain this concept, V.V.S.Aiyar uses a phraseology from physical
science. He calls the visible effects as kinetic energy and those unseen
effects as the potential energy. The result of the kinetic energy is known then
and there but the result of the potential energy is stored up somewhere in the
universe and it materialize itself in the new life of the soul which is termed
as “Karma”. Thus chapter 38, talks
about this Destiny.
Thus in
part I, the author pursues the humans to follow the path of righteousness and
ends up the first part by saying that if a man does evil, he will just carry a
load of evil which makes his next birth unhappy and cursed. Whereas the good deed
one does will load him with treasure , which will be a great blessing for him.
PART II: WEALTH:
In the
second part, Thiruvalluvar talks about politics. In this he mainly focuses on
wealth. He says that wealth cannot be enjoyed under security. These verses doesn’t
just applicable to the prince or the minister but it can also be applied to all
those who are in the thought of acquiring wealth. The author speaks about
wealth in 700 verses. The verses can be applied to both Prince and a peasant.
Thiruvalluvar
speaks of each and every function of a statesman. He
also speaks about the proper and efficient conduct of the state. A good
statesman should preserve the order in the state and has to avoid anarchy and
misgovernment. The Prince should not be above the law and he should also be
impartial and just. Liberty of speech should be given to his citizens and he
should accept the criticism as well. A good kind should not spend time in luxury
and he should be always alert and just give proper justice to his statesman. He
should protect his subject from internal and external enemies
A prince should be careful in choosing his friends. He
should choose his friend from the good and the great and should avoid the
company of low and vulgar. He should never allow vice to enter his mind. He should
select his officers with due care and supervise everything with the help of a
secret agent. He himself should have a check on his power and should have a
consideration for all. Being courageous is the most important quality for a
Prince.
As for the Ministers he should be clever, cautious,
pure-minded, devoted to Prince and
skilful in reading the hearts of men. As a courtier, he should know when, where
and how to talk and when he should not. While representing the master in the
foreign courts he should be polite and should be well versed in all arts of the
council.
The people, resources, allies, the army and fortress
are the other main body of the politics. In 22 chapters, the author speaks of
the positive and negative aspects of these members. Chapter 74 (Territory) speaks of the people
and chapter 91 to 94 speaks about the qualities of the friends and allies,
chapter 95 talks about the physician. Valluvar’s verses on Honour and Worth are
remarkable.
PART III: LOVE
This talks about the love of a single couple from the
time they meet each other for the first time till they reunite after a
temporary separation from one another. It analyzes all the moods of the lover’s
heart. V.V.S.Aiyar tells that in this third part Thiruvalluvar has excelled
Tennyson and even Shakespeare.
Thiruvalluvar speaks of love at the first sight. Just
on the basis of faith the couple does the Gandharva marriage and they reach to
each others arms even before informing their parents. But the people of the
Tamil land has perfected in this course. They undergo a martyrdom both
physically and morally in order to induce their parent to give consent for their
love on their own. Once they get the consent they go to the girls village in a
palmyra horse undergoing another kind of martyrdom. They live a happy married
life. But the husband leaves his wife alone, to go to the war with the promise
of returning back with glory and wealth.
The wife refuses to part him, but the husband persuades her to allow and later
on he could not return as said.
The pangs and pains of the love-sick wife is portrayed
beautifully in 11 chapters. The husband returns and the wife at first gets
angry on him for returning late but very soon she is happy to find her love back. The sulks(oodal) in the married life is
beautifully given in 3 chapters. Here Thiruvalluvar mentions that “boulderie is
the salt of love”. Under the title ‘Chastity’ the author gives the actions and
feelings of the chaste wife in the absence of her lord.
UNIQUENESS OF THIRUKKURAL
Valluvar speaks of all
the emotions in its depth whether it is regarding moral duties, state policy
and the hearts of lovers. Even the prophet have not emphasized the greatness of
values as Thiruvalluvar did. Vallur is par in comparison with others. Thus this
pariah weaver of Mylapore is far greater than Bhishma, Vishnu Sharma,
Machiavelli, Confucius, kalidas and even Shakespeare. On reading Thirukkural
one will know that virtue, manliness and honour triumphs over everything.
The author gives a clear distinction between private
morality and state necessity. Chapter sixteen glorifies forgiveness in private
life but when comes to state, forgiveness has only limited virtue. He must
punish the guilty. The enemy should be punished then and there and king should
not allow his enemy to grow and attain power. Neither the king should not think
of acquiring the kingdoms by wrong means.
RELIGIOUS CLAIMS
Christians claim that Thiruvalluvar wrote the book after
hearing to the teaching of the Mount. They argue that Christianity and the
teachings in the Bible are the main influences for writing Thirukkural. They believe
in the scarcely credible theory, that Thiruvalluvar received the teachings of Apostle
of St. Thomas at Mylapore.
V.V.S.Aiyar
points out that parallels can be found to the maxims of Thirukkural among great
writers in almost every great nation, but still it doesn’t mean that Thiruvalluvar
has heard to any of the saints preaching. The Christians may think that the
idea of forgiveness was given by Jesus alone but Aiyar asserts that ideas were
the common property of great minds, even four centuries before Jesus was born. So
Aiyar tells that Thiruvallur is indebted to no one in particular.
Even
the Hindus, Buddhists, Jains and Shaivas claim that Thiruvalluvar belonged to
their own religion, but he doesn’t stick on to any one religion and thirukkural
doesn’t support any one sects or religion but it sticks only to Truth, Wisdom
and Joy.
STYLE OF THE VERSE
V.V.S.AIYAR gives a few information about the verse
style for the non-native Tamilians. The word Kural means a short rhymed couplet
in which the first line is composed of four feet and the second of three feet. The
metrical foot within this short verse is used cleverly by the author. Within this
seven feet of the words the poet has given the profoundest thought of the
world.
The sparkling wit, humour, the pointed statements,
fancy, irony, naïve question, simile and the sublimity of thought found within
this seven feet were astonishing. One of the ardent admirer of Thirukkural
describes it as “a little mustard seed, but whose bore holds all the water of
the seven oceans”
PARIMELALAKAR’S COMMENTORY:
Even though 9 commentators had already interpreted
Thirukkural, the interpretation given by Parimelalakar stands out. His comments
alone bring out the beauty and the thought that in imbibed in the original. For
the modern reader this commentary is a great blessing. His commentary is brief
and to the point. Aiyar gives the example of the comments given by
Parimelalakar for verse 687, which talks about the ambassador. An ambassador
should weight the political situation of both the kings, his own status,
formalities to be observed in visiting and speaking to the Prince and also the
proper time to convey the message. An ambassador should also be prepared of
words he is going to use, the possible replies and his own supporters also.
Valluvar also gives full freedom for the ambassador to negotiate.
Aiyar gives one more example for Parimelalakar’s
commentary. For the explanation of verse 338, Parimelalakar’s interpretation was
best and apt than that is given by the other commentators. For the word ‘kudumbai’ Parimelalakar gives the
explanation as egg shell which suits best the context than nest, which was
given by other interpretators. Parimelalakar explains that the love between soul
and the body is like the love between the egg shell and the bird. The bird’s
life is confined within the egg shell for a considerable period of time but
once the bird breaks the shell and comes out it never returns back to the shell.
In the same way the soul too never returns back once it leaves the body. The body
is compared to the egg shell here and
the bird is compared to the soul of the body.
Whereas the other commentators compared it to the
nest but the bird returns back to the nest. So the comparison of the nest to
the body doesn’t bring out the real essence of the Kural. And hence the Parimelalakar’s
commentary of the Thirukkural is preserved with utmost care by the Tamil
people.
Finally V.V.S.Aiyar conclude his preface by giving
the reason for his translation. The main reason for this translation is to
spread the knowledge of the Thirukkural and also to help the retranslators who
aim to translated the Kural in different vernaculars so that even the poorest
of the poor will get a chance to read Thirukkual.
------HAPPY LEARNING---------