Wednesday, July 8, 2026

Henry David Thoreau's Walden (Where I Lived and What I Lived for)

Summary in Short

In Henry David Thoreau’s ‘Where I Lived, and What I Lived For,’ a central chapter of his masterpiece Walden, he outlines a philosophical experiment in intentional living. Moving to a cabin by Walden Pond on July 4, 1845—a date symbolic of his personal independence from social and material constraints—Thoreau seeks to strip life of its "superfluities" to discover what is essential. From an exam perspective, the text is a rich tapestry of metaphor, allusion, and social critique, focusing on themes of spiritual wealth, simplification, and the pursuit of objective truth.

 

The Philosophy of Ownership and Wealth

Thoreau begins by redefining the concept of possession, arguing that true ownership is an intellectual and spiritual act rather than a legal one. He recounts his habit of "buying" every farm in his imagination, mentally planting orchards and choosing which trees to keep before leaving the land untouched. This leads to his famous maxim: "A man is rich in proportion to the number of things which he can afford to let alone".

A key example for examination is his near-purchase of the Hollowell Farm. He was attracted to its isolation, its "dilapidated" state, and its distance from "improvement"—the very things most farmers would consider flaws. When the deal fell through, Thoreau felt he had "sold" the farm back to the owner and remained a "rich man without any damage to my poverty" because he retained the farm's beauty in his memory. He uses the metaphor of "milking the farm": while the farmer gets the "skimmed milk" of material crops, the poet/observer gets the "cream"—the spiritual and aesthetic essence.

 

The Purpose of the Walden Experiment: Living Deliberately

Thoreau’s primary motivation for moving to the woods was to "live deliberately". He wanted to confront the "essential facts of life" directly, rather than through the lens of society or tradition. He uses a vivid biological metaphor, stating he wished to "live deep and suck out all the marrow of life". Marrow represents the most nutritious and vital part of existence; by living a "Spartan-like" life of austerity and discipline, he aimed to determine if life was "mean" (degrading) or "sublime" (magnificent) through his own experience rather than hearsay.

 

The Doctrine of Simplification

Perhaps the most famous exam-related concept is Thoreau’s critique of the complexity of modern life: "Our life is frittered away by detail". He argues that humans have become like "ants," working tirelessly without questioning why, or like "pygmies" fighting "cranes"—wasting their lives on trivialities like debts, status, and social expectations.

To counter this, he offers a simple command: "Simplify, simplify". He suggests that a person should be able to count their affairs on their ten fingers and reduce their concerns from a thousand to a few. He compares modern civilization to a "cluttered" and dangerous ocean where one must navigate by "dead reckoning" just to stay afloat. In this view, technology and "improvements" (like the railroad or the telegraph) are not true progress; they are burdens that "ride upon us".

 

Intellectual Awakening and the Symbol of Morning

Thoreau places immense spiritual value on morning, viewing it as a "cheerful invitation" to make life simple and innocent. He identifies as a worshipper of Aurora, the Goddess of Dawn, and believes that every morning offers a chance for total renewal. He quotes an inscription from King Tchingthang’s bathtub: "Renew thyself completely each day; do it again, and again, and forever again".

For Thoreau, being "awake" is not a physical state but an intellectual and moral one. He critiques society for being in a "spiritual sleep," where they ignore the "poem of creation" in favor of mechanical daily tasks. He asserts that "to be awake is to be alive," and he moved to the woods specifically to "awaken" himself and his readers, much like a "rooster crowing in the morning".

 

Critique of Society: News and Communication

Thoreau is famously dismissive of "news" and constant correspondence. He believes that most news is merely a repetition of the same patterns—murders, robberies, and accidents—that offer no profound insight into human nature. He mocks people who wake from a nap only to ask, "What’s the news?" as if the latest gossip were more important than their own inner lives. He argues that people live in a "mammoth cave" of ignorance regarding their own spirits while obsessing over distant events in Spain or England. The only "news" worth knowing, he suggests, are timeless truths about virtue and self-improvement, such as the report praised by Confucius about a master trying to reduce his faults.

 

The Search for Reality: The "Realometer" and Solid Rock

A crucial philosophical point in the text is the distinction between appearance and reality. Thoreau argues that society is built on "shams and delusions"—wealth, status, and routine—which people mistake for truth. He urges his readers to "settle ourselves" and work through the "mud and slush of opinion, and prejudice, and tradition" that covers the world.

He introduces the concept of a "Realometer," a metaphorical device to measure how much falsehood has accumulated in society. By digging through these layers of illusion, one can eventually reach the "solid rock" of reality, which he calls "Place". Facing reality, even if it is painful or "mean," is better than living in a comfortable lie, because truth is the only firm foundation upon which a meaningful life can be built.

 

Conclusion: Time and Eternity

Thoreau concludes his reflections by considering the nature of time. He famously compares time to a "shallow stream" in which he goes a-fishing; while he drinks from it, he notices the "sandy bottom" and realizes how thin it is. In contrast, eternity is the deeper reality that lies beneath the surface of passing moments. His experiment at Walden was an attempt to "fish" in these deeper waters of existence, seeking a "natural wisdom" that society had forgotten.

From an exam perspective, the key to understanding Walden is recognizing that Thoreau’s physical move to the woods was merely a backdrop for an internal, spiritual journey. He advocates for non-conformity, self-reliance, and a rejection of materialism, teaching that true freedom comes from living "free and uncommitted" as long as possible. Through his stay at Walden, he proves that one can be "rich" without money, "awake" without a clock, and "connected" to the universe without the news.

 

Breaking it down further for easy understanding:

1. Spiritual vs. Legal Ownership

  • True possession lies in appreciation: Thoreau believes that legal ownership is secondary to the spiritual and intellectual appreciation of a place.
  • The Poet’s "Cream": He uses the metaphor of milking a cow to explain that while a farmer owns the material land, a poet "milks" the spiritual beauty or "cream" of the farm, leaving only the "skimmed milk" (the physical property) to the owner.
  • The Wealth of Letting Alone: One of his most vital lessons is that "a man is rich in proportion to the number of things which he can afford to let alone".
  • The Hollowell Farm: Thoreau was attracted to this farm specifically for its solitude, dilapidation, and natural imperfection, preferring it before any "improvements" like clearing rocks or cutting trees could be made.

2. The Walden Experiment and "Deliberate Living"

  • Independence Day: Thoreau moved to his cabin on July 4, 1845, symbolizing his personal independence from social expectations and materialism.
  • Living Deliberately: The central purpose of his experiment was to "live deliberately" and "front only the essential facts of life".
  • The Marrow of Life: He famously sought to "live deep and suck out all the marrow of life," meaning he wanted to extract the richest, most authentic experiences possible while stripping away unnecessary luxuries.
  • Spartan Simplicity: He admired the disciplined and austere lifestyle of ancient Sparta, wishing to "drive life into a corner" to see if it was "mean" or "sublime".

3. The Significance of Morning and Awakening

  • Spiritual Rebirth: Thoreau views morning as a "cheerful invitation" to make life simple and innocent.
  • The Definition of "Awake": He asserts that "to be awake is to be alive". He argues that while millions are awake enough for physical labor, very few are awake enough for effective intellectual thought or a poetic, divine life.
  • The Celestial Call: He compares himself to a rooster crowing to wake his neighbors from their "spiritual sleep".
  • The Poetry of Creation: Every morning is an opportunity to "renew thyself completely" and hear the constant "poem of creation" that nature sings.

4. Critique of Modern Society and Technology

  • Life Frittered by Detail: Thoreau warns that human lives are "frittered away by detail"—wasted on paperwork, schedules, and trivial concerns.
  • Technology as a Burden: He famously critiques the railroad, stating, "We do not ride on the railroad; it rides upon us".
  • Railroad Sleepers: He uses "sleepers" (the wooden beams under tracks) as a metaphor for the laborers whose lives and dignity are sacrificed to build the systems that society calls "progress".
  • The Illusion of News: Thoreau mocks the public’s obsession with "the news," arguing that most of it is merely repetitive gossip that distracts from timeless, deeper truths.

5. Pursuing Reality and Truth

  • The "Mud" of Illusion: Thoreau describes public opinion, tradition, and false beliefs as layers of "mud" that cover the truth.
  • The "Realometer": He suggests people need a device to measure how much falsehood has accumulated in society, urging them to dig down to the "solid rock" of reality.
  • Truth in the Present: He rejects the idea that truth is found in the past or future; instead, God and truth are most fully present "now".
  • Time as a Stream: He compares time to a shallow stream he goes "a-fishing in," noting that while time passes, eternity remains the deeper reality beneath the surface.
  • Intellect as a Tool: He views his mind as a cleaving tool that can cut through appearances to find the "richest vein" of wisdom.

6. Final Lessons

  • Commitment as Imprisonment: He advises staying "free and uncommitted" as long as possible, noting that being confined by a farm can be just as limiting to freedom as being in a jail.
  • The Prince and the Foresters: He uses a Hindu parable to remind students that though they may feel like "foresters" (absorbed in worldly life), their true nature is "princely" and divine.
  • The Art of Life: Thoreau teaches that the highest form of art is not painting or carving, but the ability to "affect the quality of the day" through conscious, noble living. 

In-depth Analysis
Where I Lived, and What I Lived for by Henry David Thoreau
 
Henry David Thoreau’s essay Where I Lived, and What I Lived For, taken from Walden, is a profound reflection on man’s relationship with nature, property, and freedom. In these lines, Thoreau explains his habit of imagining himself living in various places and his belief that true possession lies not in legal ownership but in spiritual and intellectual appreciation.
 
Thoreau begins by saying that at certain stages of life, people imagine every beautiful place as a possible site for a home. He himself had explored all the regions within twelve miles of his residence and mentally considered living in each of them. He says that, in his imagination, he has bought every farm he visited. Since all these farms were available for purchase and he knew their prices, he could easily imagine becoming their owner.
 
Thoreau had walked through the farmers’ lands, has tasted the wild apples growing there, had talked with the farmers about agriculture and had imagined purchasing the farms at any price.
He humorously states that he even mortgaged the farms to their owners in his imagination. Though he never obtained the legal documents of ownership, he accepted the owners’ words as if they were deeds. He also claims that he ‘cultivated’ not only the farms but also the farmers themselves by interacting with them. After enjoying a place sufficiently in his imagination, he would leave it and allow the owners to continue their work. Because of this unusual habit, his friends considered him a kind of real-estate broker.
 
Thoreau says that wherever he sat, he could imagine himself living there. The entire landscape seemed to spread outward from him. He asks, ‘What is a house but a seat?’ implying that a house is merely a place to sit and dwell. A country house, according to him, is even better because it provides closeness to nature. He discovered many beautiful places suitable for houses. Others considered these places too far from the village, but Thoreau thought the opposite—the village was too far from these peaceful places.
 
Whenever he found a suitable place, he would say, "There I might live." In his imagination, he actually lived there for an hour or even through an entire summer and winter. He imagined spending the years peacefully in such an atmosphere, enduring and enjoying the harsh winter and witnessing the arrival of spring. Thus, mentally, he had already lived in places where future inhabitants would eventually settle.
 
In a single afternoon, he could plant orchards, arrange woodlots and pastures, decide which oak and pine trees should remain standing. After making all these plans in his imagination, he would leave the land untouched. This leads to one of his most famous statements: "A man is rich in proportion to the number of things which he can afford to let alone." According to Thoreau, true wealth is in not possessing things unnecessarily.
 
His imagination became so strong that he almost bought several farms. The closest he came to real ownership was the Hollowell Farm. He had made ready the seeds and has collected materials to build a wheelbarrow. However, before the sale was completed, the owner's wife changed her mind and decided not to sell the farm. The owner then offered Thoreau ten dollars as compensation for cancelling the agreement. He humorously wonders whether he was a man with ten cents or a man who owned a farm or a man with ten dollars or all three together. However, he allowed the owner to keep both the farm and the ten dollars. He jokingly says that he had sold the farm back to the owner and even made him a gift of ten dollars. Still, he is not poverty stricken. He had his ten cents, his seeds and also the materials he bought for the wheelbarrow. Thus, he realized that he had become "a rich man without any damage to my poverty."
 
Although he never legally owned the farm, he retained its beauty in his memory and imagination. He quotes the poet William Cowper: ‘I am monarch of all I survey,
My right there is none to dispute.’ This means that one’s imagination can possess the beauty of nature more completely than legal ownership can. He gives example of poets, who often enjoy the best part of a farm. Farmers may think that poets merely take a few wild apples, but in reality, poets turn the farm into poetry by capturing its beauty forever in their poems. Here the author uses the metaphor of milking a cow. The poet has already taken the cream, leaving only skimmed milk to the farmer. In other words, the poet enjoys the spiritual richness of the place while the owner possesses only its material aspects.
 
Several things attracted him to the Hollowell Farm just as complete solitude from the nearby villages and people. It was two miles away from the village and half a mile from the nearest neighbour. The farm was also very far from the Highway and a broad field separated it from the road, giving it privacy. There was a river nearby. The owner believed that the river's fog protected the farm from spring frosts, though this did not interest Thoreau. The grey, dilapidated house in the Hallowell Farm and the barn appealed to him because they created a sense of separation from nearby occupants. The hollow trees covered with lichens and gnawed by rabbits suggested peaceful natural surroundings. This place was special because as a child, he had passed this farm while travelling on the river and remembered hearing the house dog’s bark from behind a grove of red maples. These memories increased his affection for the place. He wished to buy the farm quickly before the owner would remove the rocks or cut down the apple trees and before he uproots the young birches in the name of improvement. Thoreau loved the farm precisely because it remained in its natural and imperfect condition.
 
He says that he was prepared to carry the burden of owning the farm like Atlas carrying the world on his shoulders. He would have accepted all the labour simply to enjoy the peaceful possession of the place. However, he knew that the land would yield its richest harvest only if he could afford to leave it untouched. Although he never became a large-scale farmer, he always kept his seeds ready. He remarks that seeds improve with age. Likewise, human plans and experiences become wiser with time. He believes that when he finally plants his seeds, he will be less likely to be disappointed.
 
Thoreau gives an important lesson to humans. He says, ‘As long as possible live free and uncommitted.’ According to him, commitments and possessions often become forms of imprisonment. Therefore, it matters little whether one is confined by a farm or by a county jail because both can limit personal freedom. Thoreau quotes the Roman writer Cato from De Re Rustica. Cato advises people not to purchase a farm greedily but to visit it repeatedly and become familiar with it. Thoreau agrees with this advice. He says that instead of buying greedily, he would rather continue to walk around and appreciate the farm throughout his life and finally be buried in it, because long contemplation makes one love a place even more. Thoreau rejects materialism and celebrates imagination, simplicity, and freedom. He teaches that true ownership does not come from legal possession but from understanding, appreciating, and spiritually experiencing nature. The essay ultimately advocates a life of simplicity, independence, and intimate communion with the natural world.
 
Thoreau calls his stay in the woods an experiment in living. He spent about two years there and wants to describe what he learned from it. He says he is not writing a sad or depressing story. Instead, like a rooster crowing in the morning, he wants to awaken people from their spiritual sleep and make them think about their lives. Thoreau moved to his cabin on July 4, 1845 (Independence Day). The date is symbolic because he wanted to gain independence from society and materialism. The cabin in the woods was unfinished. It had no chimney or plastering. The walls had cracks and it protected him only from rain and not from the winter snow. Yet he loved it because it looked fresh and natural. The morning dew on the wooden windows made it appear beautiful and alive. The cabin stood among trees and hills. The winds blowing over it reminded him of heavenly music. He believed that nature constantly sings the ‘poem of creation’, but only a few people are capable of hearing it. To him, every place on earth can become as sacred as the mythical mountain Mount Olympus, if one learns to appreciate nature.
 
Before this, the only property he had owned was a tent and a boat. The tent is still with the author in his store room. His new cabin represented a step toward establishing himself in the world. However, it was still simple and open to nature. He says that a house without bird is like meat without seasoning and he proudly says that he did not imprison birds in cages but, he has caged himself among the birds. He became the neighbour of many forest birds such as Wood thrush, Veery, Scarlet tanager, Field sparrow, Whip-poor-will. Thus, he lived in close harmony with nature.
 
His cabin stood near Walden Pond, south of the village of Concord. The pond looked like a mountain lake. He used to sit in the shores of the pond and enjoy the view from there. He can see the distant mountains, falls and woods from there.  The mountain tops which were covered with the clouds was a beautiful sight to see. Every morning he saw the mist rising from the water and the sun revealing the pond gradually. The dew was lingering on the trees. The mist that moved away from the pond’s upper surface escaped into the nearby woods as if to have a secret meeting. These sights gave him peace and wonder.
 
During rainy August afternoons, the pond became especially beautiful. In this season the water became calm and reflective. The pond looked like a "lower heaven." From nearby hills, he could see distant mountains and valleys. He believed that even a small body of water teaches an important lesson: the earth is not solid and permanent but appears to float like an island. Water gives the world beauty and spiritual meaning. Though his actual surroundings were limited, he never felt confined. His imagination travelled to the prairies of the American West, to the steppes of Tartary, to distant regions of the universe. He believed that happiness comes from having a vast horizon of thought and imagination. Living at Walden made him feel far away from the busy world. He compares his isolation to being among the stars such as The Pleiades, The Hyades, Aldebaran and Altair. Though physically close to society, spiritually he lived in an entirely different universe.
 
Morning occupies a central place in this essay. The author feels that morning was a cheerful invitation to make his life simple, innocent and to be one along with Nature. He loves waking up in the early morning and he asserts that he is the worshipper of Aurora, the Goddess of dawn. He used to wake up early and bath in the pond. Thoreau quotes King Tchingthang. In his bath tub ‘Renew thyself completely each day; do it again, and again, and forever again’ is engraved. The inscription suggests human beings should constantly improve themselves. Not once, not occasionally but every single day. The faint hum of a mosquitos affect him but it reminds him of the trumpets of heroes, epic songs. The Mosquito song was like Homer's epic work The Iliad and The Odyssey for him.
 
The dawn has a cosmical effect and it is like the standing advertisement for the whole day. In the morning hour people feel active and they don’t have that sleepiness sensation. As soon as one gets up each and every part within us wakes up and stays alert at least for an hour even if not for the whole day. Thoreau says that if one’s genius is not awakened it can’t be called a day at all. People’s inner genius gets lost by the mechanical nudging’s of day to day works. The celestial call goes unheard because of the noise of factory bells.
 
One has to wake up to higher life each day. The sleep energies one’s soul and the darkness bears the fruits and thus it proves itself to be good. A man who does not believe that each day contains a more sacred and auroral hour he has stopped living his life and his future turns dark. A man’s soul is reinvigorated each day after a partial cessation, which can be termed as sleep. After each partial cessation the inner genius tries again to do something noble. The author asserts that all memorable events get shaped in the morning. As the Vedas says, all intelligence awakens in the morning. Morning is the hour of creation. Poetry, art and heroes are all the children of Aurora.
 
One who moves along with the sun intellectually, enjoys the morning thorough out the day by which the author means that one who keep awake their intelligence enjoys the whole day as it is Aurora. Morning is not dependent on the clock or the time when people start doing their labour but it is the time when one really wakes up. Moral reforms alone can help one to throw off the laziness in them and wake up intellectually. Men would achieve laurels each and every day if they are not carried away by drowsiness.
 
The author here asserts that millions are awake enough for physical labour but only one in million is awake enough for effective intellectual thoughts and only one in hundred million is awake to lead a poetic and divine life. According to Thoreau, to be awake is to be alive. He says that he has never met a man who is intellectual awake so far. One has to learn to keep themselves awake not by mechanical aids but by the infinite call of the dawn which will never fade even in one’s soundest sleep. Each man possesses an unquestionable ability to elevate his own life by constant attempts. Everyone has the capacity to make change the quality of their day and according to Thoreau that is the highest form of art than painting or carving a statue. If one is used up of his creative genius, the oracles will inform him how he can get back those golden thoughts in his life.
 
Now Thoreau explains the central purpose of his experiment. I went to the woods because I wished to live deliberately. He moved to the woods to simplify life, to eliminate unnecessary distractions, to discover life's essential truths and to learn directly from Nature. His stay at Walden was an experiment in intentional living. He wanted to confront only the essential facts of life. He stripped away luxury, possessions, and social expectations. He didn’t want to reach old age only to realize he had never truly lived. Therefore, he sought genuine experience instead of merely existing.
 
One of the most famous metaphors reads to live deep and suck out all the marrow of life. Just as marrow is the richest part inside a bone, Thoreau wants to extract the richest experiences and deepest meanings from life. He seeks intensity, authenticity, and wisdom rather than a shallow existence. By saying he wanted to live "Spartan-like," Thoreau refers to the disciplined and austere life associated with ancient Sparta. He admired strength, endurance, and freedom from luxury, believing these qualities help reveal what truly matters. He wanted to "drive life into a corner" and reduce it to its simplest terms. If life proved disappointing ("mean"), he wanted to understand that fully and honestly. If it proved magnificent ("sublime"), he wanted to know that through direct experience rather than hearsay. Thoreau says that many people are uncertain about the true nature of life and simply accept inherited religious or social formulas—for example, that humanity's purpose is to "glorify God and enjoy him forever." He is not dismissing faith; rather, he insists that each person should discover life's meaning through sincere personal experience.
 
Thoreau further adds that although humans have evolved physically, they have not evolved spiritually or intellectually. Just like the ants that spend their lives constantly working without questioning, humans too spend their entire lives working, accumulating possessions, and worrying about insignificant matters. Instead of living thoughtfully, people merely survive. The reference to the ancient myth (“changed into men”) suggests that despite becoming human beings, we continue to behave like lesser creatures. ‘like pygmies we fight with cranes…’ is an allusion to a Greek legend. Pygmies were tiny mythical people. Cranes were giant birds that constantly attacked them. Thoreau compares human life to this endless struggle. People are always battling bills, debts, status, social expectations and load themselves with unnecessary responsibilities. Instead of solving real problems, they exhaust themselves fighting trivial ones.
 
People make one mistake and instead of correcting it properly, we cover it with another mistake. Soon their lives become patched together with endless complications. Many social systems, institutions, and personal habits are merely temporary fixes rather than genuine solutions. People often praise virtues like patience, endurance and sacrifice. But Thoreau says much of this suffering could have been avoided if society were simpler. There would be less unnecessary hardship and fewer occasions requiring heroic endurance if we lead a simple life.
 
‘Our life is frittered away by detail.’ This is one of Thoreau’s most famous statements. People waste enormous amounts of energy on paperwork, money, schedules, possessions, social obligations and for endless planning. Instead of living deeply, they become trapped in small daily concerns. Thoreau humorously says that a good person only needs ten fingers or at most ten toes to count the truly important things in life. Everything else is unnecessary complexity. Instead of having hundreds of responsibilities, thousands of possessions and millions of concerns, people can reduce their life to a few essentials. Thoreau advises people to simplify their work, simplify their spending, simplify their relationship and simplify their thoughts. Only then can you truly live. He wants one to keep their financial affairs simple that one could remember them without books or ledgers. He criticizes excessive concern with wealth and complicated financial systems.
 
Thoreau compares modern civilization to a dangerous ocean filled with storms, clouds, quicksand and hidden dangers. Everyday life is becoming so complicated that people struggle simply to stay afloat. One mistake can ruin everything. Sailors use dead reckoning to estimate their position without seeing land. Thoreau says people must similarly guess their way through complicated society because life has become confusing. Only an exceptionally skilled “calculator” can survive such a system. Though Thoreau is not literally promoting starvation he asks us to reduce unnecessary consumption. Instead of 5 meals a day he ask us to choose 1. If fewer possessions and simpler habits are enough, Thoreau ask us to choose them instead of luxury.
 
Governments boast about roads, railways, canals and industries. They call it as “internal improvements.” But Thoreau says they are actually external. Real improvement should happen inside the mind, inside the soul and within human character. Thoreau asserts that luxury destroys nations. The country, like individual households, is cluttered, wasteful, luxurious and financially careless. The cure is economy, discipline, simplicity and noble purpose. He admires the strict self-discipline associated with ancient Sparta. People celebrate technological progress such as telegraphs, exports, railroads, faster transportation yet they neglect a more important question: Are we becoming better human beings? Material progress does not necessarily produce moral progress. He says that We do not ride on the railroad; it rides upon us. People believe technology serves them. Instead, People become servants of technology. Workers spend their entire lives building and maintaining systems that supposedly exist for their benefit. Railroad sleepers are wooden beams supporting the tracks. Thoreau turns them into a metaphor. Each sleeper represents a labourer. The workers sacrifice their health, freedom and dignity so that others may enjoy convenient travel. Some people literally carry civilization on their backs while others enjoy its comforts. Society values machines more than people. When a person is accidentally struck by a train, everyone is shocked. Yet society ignores the countless workers whose lives are slowly consumed by the railway system. This exposes society’s hypocrisy. Modern people rush constantly. They work endlessly for future security instead of living meaningfully in the present. People justify excessive work by claiming they are preparing for the future. Thoreau humorously replies that people take ‘a thousand stitches today’ merely to avoid ‘nine tomorrow’. He means that they overwork themselves for imagined future problems.
 
Thoreau compares society to patients suffering from this disorder. People cannot remain still. They constantly rush, travel, work and seek excitement. Stillness has become impossible for them. He says that if the church bell rang, everyone would rush to the fire. Not because they wished to help but because people are naturally attracted to excitement and disaster. Here he criticizes human curiosity and sensationalism.
 
People wake from naps asking “What’s the news?” Thoreau mocks this habit. Most news changes nothing essential about human life. People depend on constant information yet ignore deeper truths about themselves. Although people eagerly read about distant events, they remain spiritually blind. They live in the “dark unfathomed mammoth cave” of ignorance regarding their own inner lives. Thoreau says very few letters truly matter. Most communication consists of trivial information. He values thoughtful communication over constant correspondence. According to Thoreau, Newspapers repeatedly report the same kinds of stories such as murders, robberies, fires, accidents and disasters.
 
He jokes that anyone could predict newspaper reports about Spain by simply mentioning political leaders, cities and bullfights. Likewise, England’s recurring news rarely reveals anything fundamentally new. His point is that much “news” follows familiar patterns rather than providing profound insight. The only news worth knowing are the greatest truths are timeless. Instead of chasing today’s headlines, people should seek enduring wisdom about truth, virtue, self-knowledge and human nature.
 
Thoreau quotes an anecdote about Confucius (Khoung-tseu). A messenger reports that his master is trying to reduce his own faults but has not yet succeeded. Confucius praises the messenger because the report concerns about moral self-improvement, not politics or gossip. Thoreau values this is the kind of “news”. Thoreau argues that preachers should not merely repeat dull sermons. Instead, they should awaken people with a powerful call: Pause! Stop rushing, Reflect and examine your life.
 
Thoreau says that people often mistake false appearances for reality. Society values wealth, status, routine, and outward success as though they are the greatest truths, but in reality, they are only temporary illusions. If people focused only on what is truly real and meaningful, life would seem as wonderful and magical as a fairy tale or the stories in the Arabian Nights. He believes that music, poetry, beauty, and happiness would naturally become part of everyday life if people respected only what is genuine and necessary instead of chasing unnecessary desires.
 
He further explains that when people become calm, thoughtful, and wise, they realize that only noble qualities such as truth, goodness, love, and wisdom have lasting value. Small worries, fears, and temporary pleasures occupy most people's lives, but these are only shadows that distract them from reality. Unfortunately, people willingly deceive themselves by accepting social customs and habits without questioning them. They continue living the same repetitive lives because they never stop to examine whether their way of living is truly meaningful.
 
Thoreau observes that children often understand life better than adults. Children approach life with imagination, curiosity, and honesty. Adults, however, believe that age and experience have made them wiser, but often their so-called experience is simply a record of compromises, disappointments, and failures. As people grow older, they tend to lose their ability to see the world freshly and honestly.
 
To illustrate this idea, Thoreau refers to an ancient Hindu story. In the story, a prince is separated from his royal family during childhood and grows up among forest dwellers, believing that he belongs to them. Later, one of his father's ministers discovers him and reveals his true identity as a prince. Similarly, the Hindu philosopher explains that every human soul forgets its true divine nature because of worldly circumstances. Only when a wise spiritual teacher reveals the truth does a person recognize his or her real self. Through this story, Thoreau suggests that human beings forget their spiritual identity because they become absorbed in worldly life and social expectations.
 
Thoreau then criticizes the people of New England for living ordinary and shallow lives because they only see the surface of things. People accept appearances as reality without questioning them. He says that if someone were able to see only the true reality behind the buildings and institutions of society—such as churches, courts, prisons, shops, and houses—others would not even recognize those places because their deeper meaning is hidden beneath outward appearances. He encourages readers to look beyond physical objects and social institutions to understand their true purpose and value.
 
According to Thoreau, many people imagine that truth exists somewhere far away—in heaven, in ancient history, or in the distant future. He rejects this belief completely. He argues that truth exists only in the present moment. God is most fully present now, not in some distant time. Every moment of life offers an opportunity to experience what is noble, beautiful, and eternal if people pay careful attention to the reality surrounding them.
 
He also explains that the universe responds to human thoughts and ideals. Whether people move quickly or slowly through life, the path before them is shaped by the way they think and perceive the world. Therefore, instead of worrying about external success, people should spend their lives developing noble ideas and high ideals. Even if an artist or poet cannot fully achieve a great dream, future generations may continue and complete that vision.
 
Thoreau advises people to live each day calmly and deliberately, just as nature follows its own peaceful rhythm. He asks people not to become distracted by every small problem or interruption. Everyday events such as visitors arriving, bells ringing, or children making noise should not disturb one's peace of mind. Instead of allowing daily routines to control us, we should remain calm and decide for ourselves how we want to spend our day.
 
He humorously compares the rush and confusion surrounding mealtime to a dangerous whirlpool. Just as sailors avoid dangerous waters, people should avoid being overwhelmed by unnecessary busyness and social pressures. He refers to the Greek hero Odysseus (also called Ulysses), who tied himself to the mast of his ship to resist the irresistible song of the Sirens. Similarly, people should firmly control themselves and refuse to be distracted by the noise and demands of everyday life. Even if the train whistle blows or a bell rings, people should not immediately react without thinking.
 
Thoreau then uses the image of digging through layers of mud to explain the search for truth. The mud represents public opinion, prejudice, traditions, false beliefs, and appearances that cover genuine reality. He urges people to dig beneath all these layers until they reach solid rock, which symbolizes truth. Only after finding this firm foundation can individuals build meaningful lives and stable societies. He even imagines creating a "Realometer," a device that would measure how much falsehood and illusion have accumulated in society over time.
 
He explains that when a person faces reality honestly without fear or self-deception, that truth may be painful, but it is also beautiful and liberating. Whether the truth concerns life or death, people should accept it courageously. If death is approaching, they should face it honestly rather than pretending otherwise. If they are alive, they should fully engage in meaningful work instead of wasting time on trivial concerns.
 
Finally, Thoreau reflects on the nature of time. He compares time to a shallow stream in which he fishes. Although people move through time every day, eternity lies beneath it like a deeper reality. He wishes to explore this deeper truth rather than remain satisfied with the surface. He imagines fishing in the sky among the stars, symbolizing his desire for infinite wisdom and spiritual understanding. Despite his learning, he humbly admits that he knows very little and even wishes he possessed the natural wisdom he had as a newborn child.
 
In the concluding lines, Thoreau describes the intellect as a powerful tool that cuts through appearances and discovers hidden truths. He values mental and spiritual work more than constant physical labor. His mind is his greatest instrument, and he compares himself to an animal digging underground in search of hidden treasure. He believes that somewhere nearby lies the richest vein of truth and wisdom, and he resolves to begin searching for it through deep thought, self-examination, and careful observation of life.
 
Overall, Thoreau says  that true happiness comes not from wealth, social approval, or busy routines, but from living consciously, questioning appearances, discovering one's true self, and seeking eternal truths. Thoreau encourages every person to slow down, think deeply, live simply, and remain faithful to reality rather than illusion.
 

Wednesday, June 24, 2026

Cilappatikaram/Silapathikaram by Ilango Adigal (Book of Vanci)

 
Cilappatikaram was written by Ilanko Atikal around 5th c CE. It first appeared in Tamil print in 1898. The English translation of Cilappatikaram was published in 1992 by R. Parthasarathy. Cilappatikaram was the only epic that was written in India in a language other than Sanskrit. This epic consists of three books which was termed as Kandam in Tamil. The Three books are further divided into Cantos. The first book called as ‘Book of Pukar’ takes place in Chola kingdom. This revolves around the love life of Kanagi, Kovalan and Matavi. The second book ‘The Book of Maturai’ takes place in Pandiya dynasty and it revolves Kovalan's death and Kanagi's reaction to it. The Third book, ‘The Book of Vanci’ takes place in Ceral kingdom and it describes how Kanagi was Apotheosized. Each book praises their respective kingdom's rulers.  

The Book of Vanci
Canto 24 – The Round dance of the Hill Dwellers
The Main content:
The mountaineers went to the waterfalls and there they saw a woman standing under a Kino tree. She looked like Valli to them. They asked her who she was and how did she lost her breast. Kanagi said everything about herself and her husband Kovalan who lost his life due to a false accusation. She also added that to avenge her husband’s death she ruined the Madurai kingdom. On hearing this the hill dwellers praised her and rained her with flowers.

The Gods came in a golden chariot and took Kanagi along with them. The hill dwellers were surprised to see this and they hailed the woman as Goddess. The hill dwellers sang a song in Kurunji raga in praise of her by sounding the drums and by blowing the horns.
The Digression:
Girl 1 calls Girl 2, to come along with her to bath in the waterfall. Since the waterfall is flowing from the top of the mountain all kinds of leaves and flowers came along with the water and it looked like a rainbow. But still Girl 1 says that the water is so pure and assures Girl 2 that her lover Murugan will come soon.

After a very long time Girl 2 says that they have played till their eyes have turned red and its more than enough. She calls the other one to come out of the fountain and start singing song in praise of Murugan, who has killed the demon, in the shape of the mango tree. Murugan killed the demon with his spear and throwed him into the sea. She praises Murugan, the God who is present in Thiruchendur, Thiruchengodu, Palani and Swamimalai. She proclaims that the God has 6 faces, 12 hands and he was nursed by 6 mothers in Saravanapoigai. Murugan went in his vehicle peacock and he has split open the heart of the demon.

Girl 1, mocks at the mother of Girl 2 because her mother is thinking that her daughter was possessed by Kattampan, an evil spirit, without knowing that her daughter’s abnormal activities are due to her love towards Murugan. She has called the Shaman to ward off the evil spirits from her daughter but the daughter knows that no once can cure her illness.

Girls 2 assures Girl 1 that her marriage with Murugan will happen soon with the blessings of the Shiva and Parvathy. She says that they will share the news of the marriage of Murugan and Valli to all and with this marriage their secret love will come to an end.

Murugan eavesdrops this conversation and Girl 2 unexpectedly saw Murugan behind a tree and without the knowledge of Valli she went to him and talked with him. She said to Murugan, though he has come with Cadamba garland and spear the people many not accept him as Murugan since he has come in human form and not in divine form. On hearing this Murugan went away with broken heart.
Coming back to Girl 1, she says that till Murugan come back let them sing song in praise of Kanagi. They praised Kanagi, who burned down Madurai on seeing her husband’s death, as a chaste woman. Kanagi’s love is like a cobra’s hood and no one can go near her with wrong intention. She is so pure and this is proved when God restored her husband to her. She will live in heaven forever along with her husband. Whoever sing song in praise of her will be blessed. The girl tells that just like Kanagi reunited with her husband Valli too will get united with Murugan soon. Finally the girls end up their song by praising Chera king who rules the Kolli hills.

Canto 25
The Choice of a Stone
Chera Dynasty was ruled by King Cenkuttuvan. His valor is well-known. He has torn apart the demon Kadamban, who was in the Cadamba tree in the shores and has hoisted his bow emblemed flag upon the Himalayas. His sword never knew failure.

Cenkuttuvan was resting in his Silver Palace with his queen Venmal. Both of them planned to visit the mountains nearby for a change. The mountains they are planning to visit is thick with grooves and wild waterfalls. Many women accompanied the queen and a row of armies followed the King.

Cenkuttuvan who was seated in his elephant looked like the God Indra sitting in his Airavatham elephant. As per the myth, once Indra visited the groove and he created 12 hundred and 60 miles of lands full of tress with flowers of gold, rivers, islands and playhouses to enjoy. In the same way Cenkuttuvan too created a wide land scape in a sand dune near Periyar river. He built his tent near the Periyar river from the high mountains which consists of trees such as cotton wood, Kino, redwood and sandalwood. The river is covered fully with the flowers and it seemed like a flower bed. Insects are hovering above the flower bed and the river bank looked like Vishnu’s chest which is decorated with jewels.

While Cenkuttuvan and his wife Venmal were resting in such a kind of place, they heard the song of the mountain dwellers. The mountain dwellers sung about Murugan and Valli. Along with this song, the sound of pounding grain, honeycomb breakers, elephant trumpets, sound of mahouts, sound of waterfalls, sound created by the fight between elephant and tiger were also heard.

The hill dwellers on knowing that their king Cenkuttuvan has came to their mountain went and met him. They gave him many gifts such as tusk of elephants, piles of sandalwood, deer air, honey, sindoor, cardamom, pepper, coconut, mango, sugarcane, creepers, areca nuts, lion cub, baby elephants, deer, mongoose, peacock and parrots. They praised Cenkuttuvan and said to him about Kanagi and her worth. They also informed the King that Kanagi doesn’t belong to their clan and they don’t know whose daughter she is. They praised the king before leaving the place.

Setalaisathanar, the court poet said to the king about Kanagi. The poet explained how bad deeds occurred because of an anklet and how the great victorious Pandian got defeated by a woman. The poet added how Kanagi broke her anklet demanding justice. Because of this the Pandian king, who was seated in the Lion throne and who was Laxmi’s favorite fell from his glory. The Pandiya’s Queen without hearing to Kanagi’s words touched the dead Pandiya’s feet and followed him. The poet said that Kanagi has come here to tell to Cenkuttuvan all these, instead of going to her own Chola kingdom.

On hearing about Pandiyan, Cenkuttuvan felt very sad. He said that Pandya king has made things straight by sacrificing his own life. He rectified his mistake by his own death. If his nation has suffered drought or flood, people would have blamed him. But he saved his country from it by sacrificing his own life. Cenkuttuvan accept the fact that to be born as a king is not a great thing but it’s a suffering. So no one need to envy for his throne.

Cenkuttuvan asked his wife Venmal, who is chaste among the two women who had followed their husband even after death, is it Kanagi or Pandiyan’s wife? Venmal said that both are unique in their own way. Pandiyan’s wife too will reach heaven and Kanagi was made Goddess.

Cenkuttuvan wanted to build a temple for Kanagi and he wondered what stone would be apt to make her statue. He asked his councilors and they said stone from the Pothigai mountain or from the Himalayas would be apt for Kanagi’s statue. Cenkuttuvan replied that if he chose the stone from Pothigai mountain, which is very nearby to his kingdom, it would not be apt for his valor so he chose the Himalayan mountain. Himalayan mountain is the mountain of Rishis who wore wet cloths and have red hair. Most of the rishis are brahmins who wore 3 stringed cords around them. Cenkuttuvan questions what if those rishis reject to give a stone for Kanagi’s statue. But he himself tells that they wont reject if they come to know the reason.

Next Cenkuttuvan thinks what to do if the Himalayan rulers refuse to give the stones. He declares that if such a situation arise he will fight and kill them just like Shiva who fought with them to marry Parvathy. Cenkuttuvan proclaims that he will make the Himalayan rules to realise the uncertainty of life and he will make a garland of Mantaram flower and Kino flower. So Cenkuttuvan got into a war spirit and he planned to moved towards north on an auspicious day.

As per the customs, a big feast will be given to all the soldiers before going to the war field. They will wear the Kadamba and Vanji garland as a symbol for war. Not only humans but the even the animals and swords are decorated with this garland. Vilavan Kotai one of the soldiers shared the victorious deed of Cenkuttuvan. Cenkuttuvan has made the Pandya and Chola king to run away from war in fear of their life in the war field of Sengalam. Many other kings such as Konganar, Ariyar, Kalignar were defeated by Cenkuttuvan in various wars.

Not only just the Tamil king but Cenkuttuvan has even defeated the Aryans of the North. Vilavan Kotai remembers how Cenkuttuvan controlled the enemies elephant as if they were cats. The war with the Arya kings of the north in the past was because Cenkuttuvan’s mother wanted to bath in Ganga. His courageousness in the war with the Aryas has made even the Yaman, the God of death feel surprised.

After telling all this Vilavan Kotai, advised the king to write a letter to the Arya kings instead of going to war and wasting his energy and time. A letter is more than enough to make the Arya kings to fall in Cenkuttuvan’s leg and give away the stone. Alumpilvel, another soldier suggested that a letter is not needed because the court consists of many spies so a open statement from the king is more than enough. Hence Cenkuttuvan, as said by Alumpilvel accepted to give an open statement and Cenkuttuvan went back to his palace.

 A messenger was seated on an elephant’s back and was made to announce that Cenkuttuvan who has already hoisted his flag in the Himalayas has planned to take a stone from there and the Arya kings have to pay their taxes when the king visits there. Anyone who fail to do so will suffer and if anyone dares to say no to Cenkuttuvan they will die. This message was conveyed along with a drum beat.

Canto – 26
Removing the Stone
Cheran Cenkuttuvan, who is seated in his throne is discussing with the priest, astrologer, renowned ministers and the commander of the army regarding waging war against the Arya kings. The priest said that from one of the Rishi’s he came to know that the Arya kings, particularly Kangan and Vijayan blabbered that the Tamil kings were able to capture Himalayas only because they were not there. On hearing this Cenkuttuvan got angry. He proclaimed that he will make the Arya kings to lift the stone for Kanagi statue in their head and he pledged that if he can’t do this with his sword, he can be considered as a worthless king.

The priest, who tried to pacify Cenkuttuvan, said that the Arya kings gave such a statement regarding the Pandya and the Chola kings and not of the great, valorous Cenkuttuvan. Everyone knows that no one can stand against Cenkuttuvan. The Astrologer said that the day and time is auspicious, all the stars are favorable, so the king Cenkuttuvan can start moving towards north waging the war.

Cenkuttuvan felt very happy on hearing this. He ordered to send the sword and parasol, decorated with Panambu garland, amidst great celebration to the north immediately. The drum sound that was given during this celebration shook the Adisesan’s head. All the four kinds of armies (infantry, elephantry, cavalry, chariots) headed by the bow flag marched forward. Though they started at night time, the light was emitted from all the directions. The army was moving forward to reward hell to the enemies. The king’s elephant, which was given high respect, was made to eat even before the king ate, and the King’s sword was kept upon the elephant and all the four armies, along with councilors, courtiers, priest, tax collectors, guards followed the elephant.

The king gave a grand feast to the rest of his armies. All were wearing the Vanchi flower. The feudal lords paid their taxes to Cenkuttuvan. The king who never bows before anyone prayed to lord Shiva with his head bowed and the fire that was burning in the altar spread on all sides. A priest came with the blessed garland from Thiruvanathapuram Vishnu temple. Cenkuttuvan started moving towards north by holding Shiva’s sandals in his head and Vishu’s garland in his shoulders.

The king’s presence in the elephants was a treat to common man’s eyes because he seemed like Vishu himself. The girls sang song and danced in praise of the king. Like Vishnu who was a nightmare to the demons, Cenkuttuvan too was like a nightmare to his enemies. They were walking towards the Ganges seashore crossing the mountains and plains. The army was such a huge in number that even the mountains bent when the army walked upon it and the plains trembled and new ways were formed.
After travelling for several months they reached Nilagiris and the King planned to rest there for a while. The soldiers constructed tents and the land was so happy to hold the divine foot of Cenkuttuvan. Like the sun bringing grace to Earth, Cenkuttuvan’s feet added grace to the land.

The saints who were passing through Nilagiris(Karnataka) stopped in mid-air to have a view of Cenkuttuvan who was in par with Vishnu. The King wished the saints, who looked like a bright light. The saints praised Cenkuttuvan and added that he got the blessings of the Shiva. They said that they were going to Pothigai mountains to do penance. They asked Cenkuttuvan to take care of the Himalayan Rishi’s and not to hurt them in anyway. Kongan, the Karnataka artists who were having black and curly hairs came to see the king. The artist performed before the king with full respect depicting their culture. They sung about the Winter. The Kudagu artist sung about the rainy season. They praised the rainy season because all the soldiers will return home during this season. The other artist’s too came and sung song in praise of the King and blessed him to get victory in the war. Cenkuttuvan gave apt gifts to all the artists and everyone left happily.

A guard enters with a message from one of the alliances of north. The messenger informed that 120 dancing girls, 208 singers along with their instruments, 100 jesters, 96 saints, 100 chariots, 500 elephants, 10,000 horses, 20,000 carts and 1000 messengers with Sanjayan as the leader is waiting outside to meet the king. Sanjayan bowed to the King and informed that he has come with a message from a friendly king named Satakarni. His king Satakarni, has sent a message to Cenkuttuvan through Sanjayan stating that if the king has come only for the stone to engrave the image of Goddess Kanagi, he himself can do it. He assures that he will hand over the stone after washing it in the divine Ganges. But Cenkuttuvan says that, since the Arya kings, Kanakan and Vijayan has let loose their tongues and has mocked at the Tamil King’s courageousness, a proper and apt reply should be given to them by himself. So, he himself want to march like the God of death and teach the Arya kings a proper lesson. Cenkuttuvan ask Satakarni to make arrangements to cross the Ganges River. Before moving forward towards the north, Cenkuttuvan gave a proper responses to all the kings who paid their taxes.

Cenkuttuvan’s army crossed the Ganges with the help of the boat which was made ready by Satakarni. As soon as they reached the north of Ganga, the war started. In ancient Tamil culture Vanji kings refer to one who go for war and Kanji kings refer to one who fights to protect themselves. So, in this context Cenkuttuvan stand as the Vanji king and the Aryas stands as the Kanji kings. Uttaran, Vicitiran, Rudran, Bairavan, Kanagan and Vijayan marched forward challenging the Tamil kings.

Just like a lion which feels happy on seeing a group of elephants when it was very hungry Cenkuttuvan too felt happy on seeing the Kanji kings. The flags that were held by the armies hid the sun’s rays. The sounds of drums, conches, trumpets, cymbals echoed in all the 8 directions.

Cenkuttuvan’s armies were of different capabilities. One group had bow on their shoulders, whereas the others had spears in hands, many soldiers had shield in their chest made of leathers, and many acted as riders of chariots, many were seated on the elephant back and there were swift horse riders too. Because of the movement of such a big army dust raised to the level of sky and it hid the people’s eyes. The bells tied to the elephant’s neck sounded because of its movement and the air that entered the conches produced a different kind of sound.

The soldiers on foot fought first. The head and the shoulders of the enemy soldiers flew on all sides. A small hill was formed by the head cut down by the Cenkuttuvan’s soldiers. The Ghosts with big eyes sang song and the headless dead bodies danced to it. The blood of the dead soldiers ran like a river and the ghost drank it. The Arya kings fell down dead.

In the war field, the destruction caused by Cenkuttuvan’s army left the Kanji kings speechless. The wheels of the chariots were destroyed, elephants, horses fell down dead, innumerable Aryan soldiers died. Yaman, the god of death took the life of all-in-one day. Cenkuttuvan announced his victory to the whole universe. Cenkuttuvan and his soldiers celebrated their victory by wearing Panambu and Thumbai garland. The King imprisoned 52 chariot warriors along with Kanagan and Vijayan.

The remaining soldiers escaped from the war field for their dear life. They disguised themselves as women with braided hairs, monks smeared with ashes, minstrels and dancers to save their life from Cenkuttuvan’s wrath. They throwed away the sword and spear and ran away. Cenkuttuvan, to instill fear in others made the elephant to walk upon the dead bodies just like an ox walking on the paddy field.
Many praised the king’s victory. The Goblin praised the King and they compared Cenkuttuvan to Lord Vishnu. He was holding the dead one’s head in his hands. It compared this battle to the churning of the ocean by the God and the Demons, to the Lanka war of Ramayana. The goblins cooked food by placing the three human skulls as the stove and placing the skull of the elephant as the vessel and using its own hands as the ladle. It praised ‘long live Cenkuttuvan’.

Cenkuttuvan ordered his soldiers to protect the sacred fire of the rishi’s. Villavan Kothai, the commander-in-chief took the stone from the golden Himalayas to crave a statue for Kanagi.

Canto 27
The Lustration
Pattini Goddess image was engraved in the stone which was taken from Himalayas. Kanagi was apotheosized. Cenkuttuvan made Kanagan and Vijayan to lift the stone on their heads. Yamadharma Raja felt happy about this war. The war between the Devas and Asuras took place for 18 years, the Lanka war in Ramayana took place for 18 months, and the Kuruksetra war in Mahabarata took 18 days whereas Cenkuttuvan finished the war in 8 hours. He crossed back the Ganges along with his soldiers. He washed the stone in the Gangai River with the help of the Brahmanas as per the custom. In the southern side of the Ganga, they rested for a while. Cenkuttuvan made the Arya kings to build a big camp consisting of palace, arches, islets, garden, grooves, lily ponds and much more.

Once the war came to end, Cenkuttuvan honored all the warriors who fought for him and who made the Arya kings to run away in fear. He honored the warriors who died in the war field too. Cenkuttuvan cried on seeing the soldiers who were hurt and badly injured. The dead soldiers reached heaven and the Gods in heaven were happy to welcome them. The wife of the soldiers too died along with them. He honored all the commander-in-chief and all those living relatives of the dead. He welcomed each and every one separately and gifted them a golden chain and he adorned himself with the palm leaves.

Matalan, a learned brahmin entered Cenkuttuvan’s court and informed that Matavi’s song was the reason for Kanagan and Vijayan’s destruction. In the court no one knows about Matavi and they laughed at Matalan for telling that a girl is reason behind the Arya kings destruction. Cenkuttuvan asked who is Matavi to Matalan. Matalan explained how Matavi sang a song and it was misunderstood by Kovalan. He thought Matavi is singing the song in fond memory of some other men which led to their separation. As a consequence Kovalan gets re-united with Kanagi and they both went to Maturai but unfortunately Kovalan died because of a false accusation and Kanagi who burnt Maturai claiming justice had become a Goddess.

After telling all this Matalan said that he belongs to Pothigai mountain and his guru is Agastiyar and he used to bath in the Kumari River. He reached Maturai by fate and came to know about how the undefeatable king was defeated by Kanagi. He said about the saint Kavunti, who joined as a companion with Kanagi and Kovalan on their way to Madurai, who got so angry on hearing about Kovalan’s death. But on hearing that the Pandya king died her anger got subsided. But somehow, she thought that it’s because of her bad luck Kovalan died and hence she starved herself to death.

Matari, who promised Kavunti saint to take care of Kanagi and Kovalan in Maturai commits suicide by falling into a fire pit as soon as she came to know about the death of Kovalan. Matari before dying proclaimed that Kovalan was innocent and it is the Pandiya King, Neduncheliyan who had given the wrong judgement.

Matalan added that he went to Poompukar, the capital of Chola kingdom to inform about the state of Kanaki and Kovalan to their relations. On hearing about his son’s death Kovalan’s dad, gave away all his wealth to charity and became one among the saints of Indra. Kanaki’s father too became a saint. Both Kanaki and Kovalan’s mother starved themselves to death. Matavi, on hearing this tonsured her head and joined in a Buddhist nunnery. Before joining the nunnery she gave away her daughter Manimekalai to her mother with a request to keep her daughter away from courtesan’s life. Matalan felt that his words was the reason behind the deaths and so to get rid of this sin and to come out of his own guilty consciousness he came to bath in the Ganga River.

Cenkuttuvan asked to Matalan about the current state of Madurai kingdom. Matalan after praising Cenkuttuvan, who killed 9 kings in one go to help the Chola king, Killivalavan and who destroyed the neem tree that belong to Pallayan king said that after the death of Neducheliyan, Vetrivel Cheliyan became the king with Korkai as his capital. To get rid of the sin the Padyan king did to Kanagi, Vetrivel Cheliyan did a lot of sacrifices and he killed 1000 goldsmiths in one day to atone for the mistakes. Vetrivel Cheliyan has took over the responsibility of Madurai, when it suffered without a king.

Next Cheran Cenkuttuvan asked about the Killivalavan, the Chola king, who is also Cenkuttuvan’s brother-in-law. Matalan said that the Cholo king is ruling his kingdom is a very apt way and he has destroyed the three fortress and saved the Gods. Matalan praised the past rulers of Chola kingdom, especially Cibi Chakkaravathy, who gave his own flesh for a hawk and about a Chola king who saved a dove whose leg was hurt. Matalan praised that the land where Cauvery runs will not face any danger. Cenkuttuvan felt happy of Matalan and awarded him gold equal to his weight.

Once the important errand was over, Cenkuttuvan thought of his wife Venmal and he know that she will feel sad because of his absence. It was almost 32 months since Cenkuttuvan left his country Vanci. Cenkuttuvan passed through the tents made out of cloths and rope. The craftsman who has designed the camp has constructed separate street for chariots, elephants and soldiers. He praised the skill of the craftsman who constructed the camp. The whole camp had a fence made out of cloth.

Cenkuttuvan decided to take Kanagan and Vijayan to Vanci to show them off to Chola and Pandya kings. Cenkuttuvan started moving towards Vanci on a early morning when the bees were surrounding the flowers, that were bloomed near the Ganga river, to collect the honey from them.

In Vanci, queen Venmal was missing the king. Venmal was in the wealthiest palace. The palace was decorated with pearl garlands, and it contained beautiful drawings and the cot was studded with pearls and diamonds and the bed is made up of swan feathers. Even being in such a rich palace, the queen could not enjoy a peaceful sleep. The maidservants informed the queen about Cenkuttuvan victory and urged her to dress up and be merry to welcome the king. The whole country jumped in celebration mood on hearing the victory of the king.

All the five landscapes (Thinai) people made preparation to welcome the king. The hill dwellers (The Kurunji thinai people) through the song asked to elephants to pave way for the King. The elephants that have entered the fields, has eaten up the crops and have slept there itself when the guards men failed to protect the land after drinking the soma.

The agricultural land dwellers (Marutham) praised Cenkuttuvan for defeating the Aryas and asked their folks people to keep ready their Bullock to plow. They know that king will release his enemies slaves on his birthday and since Cenkuttuvan’s birthday is arriving soon they can no more do the plowing with the slaves.

The forest dwellers (Mullai)  who were bathing in the Thamaraparni river asked their folks men to bath their cows in Thamaraparani, so that their cows can also join Cenkuttuvan’s army. The Thamaraparani river consists of many colours of flowers and it seems like a rainbow.

The Coastal dwellers (Neithal) sang song in praise of Cenkuttuvan saying that he is coming to be with his queen. These girls who were singing the song were wearing a bracelet made up of pearls taken from the deep sea.

Queen listened to these song and felt happy. Cenkuttuvan arrived Vanci wearing the vagai garland. Seated on the state elephant Cenkuttuvan’s presence was a treat to the common man.

Canto 28
The Dedication of the Memorial Stone
In an evening time, Cenkuttuvan reached Vanci with his victorious sword and parasol. The women lighted the divine lamp and prayed to the Almighty for a long and happy life for the King. The women treated the soldiers who were hurt by the elephant’s tusk. The soldiers who were hurt in the chest by spear, sword and arrows were also taken care of by their wives.

The soldier’s wife made their husbands happy by smiling heartily though they were unhappy on seeing their husband’s suffering. They sang songs about Kurunji and Palai to make their husbands forget the pain. Nature seemed more pleasant on the full moon day. The terraces, flowers, groves, pavilions and balconies were encompassed by the moon light. The poet here tells that like the Cenkuttuvan’s pleasant face the moon raised. Cenkuttuvan’s palace which was covered with the moon light, looked like the Meru mountain which was encircled by the sea. Venmal accompanied with her maid servants who were carrying lamps in their hands and were singing songs along with a rhythmic music, reached the terrace. The ladies were holding perfumes which were spreading out sweet fragrance. Cenkuttuvan too joined Venmal in the terrace.

In the pleasant moon light, Paraiyur’s Chakkaiyan imitated the dance of Shiva. They depicted the dance of Shiva which was named as Kotticcetam, where Lord Shiva dance with half as Uma and the other half as himself. Chakkiyan dressed aptly, his eyes showed 1000 emotions and his hair flew in all sides. The anklet in Shiva’s side leg sounded melodiously. But on Uma’s side there was no movement. He praised the king and queen before leaving the place.

Nilan, who came with Madalan and the priest said to Cenkuttuvan that he went to Poompukar, the capital of Chola kingdom with Kanagan and Vijayan. Killivalavan though felt happy of Cenkuttuvan’s victory didn’t feel good about showing off Vijayan and Kanagan like this to others. Even the Pandya King, Vetrivel Chelliyan said that Cenkuttuvan should have given the Arya king’s Parasol to the dancing girls and should have thanked Shiva for giving him victory instead of bringing the warriors who ran away from the war field, like this to show off them as if in exhibition.
  
Cenkuttuvan laughed with scorn on hearing this. Madalan said that Cenkuttuvan had proved his valor many times, especially when he defeated the elephants that sleeps under pepper plant in Viyalur, and defeating over 9 kings at the same time in Nerivayil, and his victory in Idumbil. Madalan advised the king to give up his wrath. After wishing the king that he will have more days to live than the particles of sand in the river bed of Anporunai, Matalan said that 50 years have passed for the king and in these 50 years he has spent more time in participating in war than in doing sacrifices. Since life, wealth and youth is temporary and good deeds alone is permanent Matalan advised the king to do a lot of good deeds and sacrifices.

Matalan reminds Cenkuttuvan about his ancestors who died in war though they have exhibited great valor in war. Neducheralathan, who defeated the Kadambans(Pirates) and destroyed their divine tree, died. Another one Chera king hoisted his bow flag emblem in Himalya even before Cenkuttuvan, too died. A Chera king who helped a brahman to reach heaven for composing song also died. A king of his line stopped Yaman and forced him to take life in an order, too died. The king who defeated the undefeatable Yavanas too died. One King bathed in the Ayirai River to escape death, but he too died. Another king who did a great sacrifice by keeping the ghost as the guardians too died. Matalan tells that all these deaths imply that this body is fragile. He adds that wealth too is temporary and Kanagan and Vijayan are the best example for this. Youth too is temporary and Cenkuttuvan is the best example for this because even though Goddess Laxmi resides in his heart, grey hair is visible in his head.

Matalan further tells that the human soul will reborn as animals or demons. Just like an actor who put different costumes before entering the stage the human soul too takes different forms in each birth. The statement that actions of former birth determine the life after death is true. Since in this life Cenkuttuvan’s soul has chosen a great body, it should not end like a normal man’s life but it should reach great heights. Matalan advises the king to do a lot of sacrifice and offering so that his soul will escape from rebirth.

Matalan ask the king to do the good deed of sacrifice immediately without postponing it because no one knows about their death. When the time comes no one can stop the soul from leaving the body. He asked the king to do a lot of sacrifice along with Venmal. Cenkuttuvan was moved by Matalan’s words and asked the learned brahmins, priests and experts in Vedas to gather immediately and do the offerings and sacrifices.

Cenkuttuvan ordered to release Kanagan and Vijayan and made them to stay in Velavikko palace which was in Vanci’s outskirt. He asked Villavan Kothai to take good care of them. They will be sent back to their own places once the sacrifices were over. He further ordered Alumpilvel to release all the prisoners and also to pay back the taxes collected from them.

Through Kanagi, Chola king has learnt that the sinner should be punished if the chastity of the women has to be saved. If a chaste woman is in danger, it means that the king is not ruling properly. The Pandya king learnt that if a king fails in giving proper justice, then his whole kingdom will collapse. The Arya king learnt that if the Tamil Kings were challenged, they will not stop until they get victory. The Chera king proved that the southern king’s wrath will not be appeased till they fulfil their vows.

In the end Cenkuttuvan tells that let’s all worship lord Kailasa before worshipping Kanagi. He ordered to decorate Kanagi’s statue with the best jewels and to pour flowers on her. He made the guardian deities to stand at the entrance and the Kanagi’s sculptor to be place in the inner sanctum of the temple. He asked to worship Kanagi everyday with offerings.

Canto -29
Benediction
This canto starts with a preface of how Cenkuttuvan defeated the Aryas by marching towards Gangai River. Cenkuttuvan, the son of Ceralatan got angry when he heard how the northern kings ridiculed the valor of Tamil kings. So he went for a war, defeated them completely and made them to carry the stone on their heads. Cenkuttuvan raised a temple for Kanagi, who stood before the Pandya king with tears in her eyes until he fell dead.

Masathuvan, Tevanti, and Kanagi’s foster mother and her close friends visited Madurai and to Aiyai, Matari’s daughter house, and then by crossing the Pothigai hills has come to Cenkuttuvan’s palace. Tevanti said that she is the friend of the girl who was born in Himalayas, whom all the three kings protect and worship. The other one said that she is the foster mother of the girl who has a very big eyes and who have never hated Matavi and who accepted Kovalan whole-heartedly and crossed the dry lands along with him. The close friends of Kanagi informed that Kanagi left Poompukar without informing anybody, not even to them.

Tevanti lamented that Kanagi said about her bad dream but still she could not understand the inner meaning of it. If she has understood it, she would have saved her from the danger. She asked whether Kanagi know about the death of her mother and mother-in-law. Foster mother lamented that Kanagi’s father in-law, Masathuvan on knowing that a goldsmith was the reason behind Kovalan’s death felt very sad and became a monk. She too asked Kanagi that she knows about this. Kanagi’s friend lamented about how Matavi became a Buddhist nun and also made her daughter to lead a simple life. Tevanti pointing to Aiyai lamented that her mother, Mantari died because she could not safeguard Kanagi.

Suddenly Cenkuttuvan saw a vision in sky. He saw a God in sky wearing a golden anklets, bangles, rare diamonds and many other gold ornaments. That vision like a lightning vanished away.

A celestial voice is heard and it is of Kanagi’s. The Goddess said that Pandyan king is blameless this is proved when he was welcomes as a guest in Indra’s palace. She added that now Kanagi is the daughter of Pandya and she promises that she will be like a guardian angel to the Chera country.

The Vanci’s girls gathered around and sang song in praise of Kannagi, the daughter of Pandya. They also praised Pandyan. Kanagi and Kovalan suffered because of their past deeds. Though Kanagi’s tears were the reason for Neduchiliyan’s downfall, his deeds will live forever. Not his deed alone but all those kings deed who come in the line of Neduchiliyan. They praised Cenkuttuvan too. It was because of him Kanagi became the daughter of Himalayas. They praised that the line of Cenkuttuvan too will live forever. At the end the girls praised the Chola dynasty and its capital Poompukar.

Song of the Wooden Ball: While the women’s play in stones they will sing song. Usually three girls will play with this wooden ball and the song they sing while playing this is termed as ‘ammanai’. One girl will raise questions through her song and the other one will give answer to it. Who is the strongest king, who rules all the world and who guards the fortress is the first question raised and the other girl replies as the Chola king. The second question was which victorious king was praised by the heaven for giving away his own flesh to save a dove? He is also the king who comes in the line of a king who killed his own son for a sake of a cow. (Manuneethi Cholan). Again the girl replies it is Cenkuttuvan and they praised him. The third question is, who is the king who engraved the tiger emblem in Himalayas? And the girls replies that it is Imayavarman Neducheralathan and hence they start praising Pukar. And the final question is why they are singing song while playing with the stone and the reply is to spread the King’s praise they are doing to.

Song of the Ball: This is a game where many balls will be thrown into the air and they have to catch those balls without missing it. While the girls were playing this, they looked like a creeper and their necklace was shaking and the echoes from the jewels is heard. They are singing Tennavan’s praise who held Indra’s garland and they also praised Ukkrakumara Pandya who casually carried the heavy necklace. Though the girls were moving like a lightning to catch the balls they didn’t stop their song.

The Song of the Swing: Two rich girls who are enjoying in the swing were singing songs in praise of Cenkuttuvan who had defeated the Kadambans. They praised the bow flag too. They praised Peruchotru Uthayacheralathan who gave food to all those who participated in the war held between Pandavas and Gauravas. The Yavanas, who speak weirdly and the Aryas were also defeated by the Chera king and they sang song in praise of him.

Song of the Pestle: The girls were seated under the Kanchi tree and they used sugarcane as their pestle and they were crushing the pearls with the help of their pestle. And while they were doing this, they praised the king who posses the Tiger flag and had a great chariot. Few other girls crushed pearls in Coral pestles and they praised the Pandya king who easily carried the heavy garland given by Indra. Few other girls in a pestle made of elephant’s tusk, crushed pearls using the sandal wood mortar praised the Chera king who won over the Kadambans.

Canto 30

The Granting of a Favor

All the Chola kingdom people were gathered together to witness the installation of the Goddess Kanagi. Cheran Cenkuttuvan asked to Tevanthi about Manimekalai and why she joined in nunnery. Tevanthi said the Manimekalai is the daughter of Kovalan and Matavi and Chitravathi is the foster mother of Manimekalai. Tevanthi informed that Manimekalai didn’t follow her family customs of decorating themselves.


Once Madhavi and Chitravathi while discussing, said that Manimekalai having dark black hair and a cool charming innocent eye was so pure. Her coral-like lips and pearl white teeth made her more attractive than any other women but still she didn’t learn the dance of her family. Chitravathi was worried about Manimekalai’s future.


On hearing this Madhavi called Manimekalai and tonsured her head and made her a monk. The kings of the south felt sad on knowing about this. They felt sad like the one who has dropped a priceless jewel into deep sea. Manimekalai herself said that renouncing the worldly pleasure is her own decision.


Pasanthusathuvan, husband of Tevanti, soul enters Tevanthi’s body. She stood in a state of trance. Her whole body was shivering, her eyes turned red, her hair were spread through her back, her eyebrows were shivering and starts speaking in a weird tongue.


Addressing Madalan, the possessed Tevanti said Cenkuttuvan is unique among the Chera kings and added to sprinkle the water on Arattan Cetti twins who were present in the gathering and also on Cetakkutumpi of Thiruvanthapuram who serves in the Tirumal temple. Possessed Tevanti said to Madalan that he gave Madalan the water in the temple which he bought from one particular stream which consists of many kinds of stone.  If one baths in that spring they will be reminded of their previous birth. The possessed Tevanti asked Madalan to sprinkle the water on the 3 little girls.


Cenkuttuvan was shocked on hearing this. Madalan said about Pasanthusathuvan to Cenkuttuvan. He said a lady named Malati gave milk to a child born out from her husband’s second wife but unfortunately the child died. Malati prayed to Pacantuvan and the God himself gave birth as the child. This child grew up and married Tevanti. After 8 years he showed his wife his real form and left asking her to come to his temple. This Pasanthusathuvan appeared before Madalan and gave him the water and ordered him to keep it safely. As Pasathusathuvan himself said. Madalan sprinkled that water on the three little girls.


Once the water was sprinkled on them, the three little girls got the memory of their previous birth. 

One among that little girl was Kanagi’s mother and she started expressing her grief for Kanagi’s death. She lamented that Kanagi was like a friend to her and without her she is suffering a lot and requested her to come back. Another little girl was Kovalan’s mother and she lamented that Kanagi stayed with her even when Kovalan left her and she requested Kovalan to return to her. Mandari lamented that she just left Kanagi in her house to take a bath in Vaigai and when she returned, she could not find her and she questioned where she was. These little girls spoke like elders and Cenkuttuvan wondered over the things said by them. Madalan explained that both Kanagi and Kovalan’s mother were so much attached with Kanagi and so they were reborn as twins. Mantarai too loved Kanagi so much so she too was reborn. Madalan says that people who do good deeds will reach heaven thereby escaping rebirth but if someone loves a lot, they will be reborn again though they would have done a lot of good deeds. It’s the love of Kanagi and Kovalan’s mother and the love of Mantari towards Kanagi had made them reborn. Madalan added that since Cenkuttuvan was born with Shiva’s blessings he was able to make a statue for Kanagi. The King felt so happy on hearing it and he ordered daily pooja to be done for Kanagi and Tevanti to take the responsibility of the temple. He went around Kanagi’s statue three times and the Arya kings too joined with him. The celestial voice of Kanagi gave the blessings to all.


All the kings including Cenkuttuvan praised the Kanagi and they all felt so happy as if they have attained salvation. After all the kings left Ilango Adigal went to the temple. Tevanti, possessed by Kanagi said to Ilango Adigal that in his childhood when he was seated with his father, an astrologer said that he will inherit the throne and Ilango go angry on hearing this. So to make his elder brother as the king, Ilango Adigal moved to east and before the sages he renounced the throne and attained the kinship of everlasting bliss beyond the world.


The author address the readers and says that those who read this story should follow the path of virtue, they should never cause pain to other, should fear to tell lies, should avoid rumors, should give up eating meat, should be charitable, should never forgot the good they have received, should avoid bad company, should avoid false evidence, should not destroy the truth, should avoid other men’s wives, should care for the dying and should avoid drinking and theft. He further adds that youth, wealth and body are unstable and no one can escape fate so the author asks the reader to do lot of good virtues.


The CODA(Composition): ‘The Book of Vanci’ ends with the praise of all the three kings, and in particular it speaks about the gloriousness of Vanci, the splendor of festivals, the joyful subjects, their wealthiness, appearance of Devas, the sword warriors and much more. The author asserts that only a glimpse of Cenkuttuvan’s valor is given here.


Epilogue: Cilappatikaram ends with the story of Manimekalai and like a mirror it reflected the essence of Tamil culture. It compromised of five landscapes and in it lived the God and humans who practice Virtue and love. It was written in a noble language in perfect rhythm about the themes of love(aham) and war(puram).

Henry David Thoreau's Walden (Where I Lived and What I Lived for)

Summary in Short In Henry David Thoreau’s ‘Where I Lived, and What I Lived For,’ a central chapter of his masterpiece Walden , he outlines a...